by Allan Fish
Best Picture 8½, Italy (7 votes)
Best Director Federico Fellini, 8½ (13 votes)
Best Actor Richard Harris, This Sporting Life & Marcello Mastroianni, 8½ (7 votes each, TIE)
Best Actress Julie Harris, The Haunting (7 votes)
Best Supp Actor Melvyn Douglas, Hud (10 votes)
Best Supp Actress Patricia Neal, Hud (5 votes)*
Best Cinematography Gianni di Venanzo, 8½ (8 votes)
Best Score Georges Delerue, Le Mépris (8 votes)
Best Short The House is Black, Iran, Farough Farrokhzad (9 votes)
NOTE: Patricia Neal actually tied on 5 with Julie Christie for Billy Liar, but as 3 people also voted for Neal as actress, it seemed only fair to select her for winner.
—
so onwards…
—
1964
—
Best Picture/Director
—
Aa bakudan (Japan…Kihachi Okamoto)
Act of Murder (UK…Alan Bridges)
All These Women (Sweden…Ingmar Bergman)
Amor y Sexo (Mexico…Luis Alcoriza)
Angélique, Marquise des Anges (France…Bernard Borderie)
The Art of Vision (US…Stan Brakhage)
Assassination (Japan…Masahiro Shinoda)
At Midnight I Will Take Your Soul (Brazil…José Mojica Marins)
Bande à Part (France…Jean-Luc Godard)
The Beauty Jungle (UK…Val Guest)
Becket (UK…Peter Glenville)
Before the Revolution (Italy…Bernardo Bertolucci)
The Best Man (US…Franklin J.Schaffner)
Black God, White Devil (Brazil…Glauber Rocha)
Black Sun (Japan…Koreyoshi Kurahara)
Blood and Black Lace (Italy…Mario Bava)
The Body Confession (South Korea…Cho Keung-ha)
Castle of Blood (Italy…Sergio Corbucci, Antonio Margheriti)
Charulata (India…Satyajit Ray)
Cheyenne Autumn (US…John Ford)
Could I But Live (Japan…Zenzo Matsuyama)
Courage for Every Day (Czechoslovakia…Evald Schorm)
Culloden (UK…Peter Watkins)
Day Dream (Japan…Tetsuji Takechi)
De l’Amour (France…Jean Aurel)
Dear John (Sweden…Lars-Magnus Lindgren)
Il Deserto Rosso (Italy…Michelangelo Antonioni)
Diamonds of the Night (Czechoslovakia…Jan Nemec)
The Diary of a Chambermaid (France…Luis Buñuel)
Doctor Strangelove (UK…Stanley Kubrick)
Dry Summer (Turkey…Metin Erksan)
Empire (US…Andy Warhol)
The Enchanted Desna (USSR…Julia Solntseva)
Escape from Japan (Japan…Yoshishige Yoshida)
Fail Safe (US…Sidney Lumet)
The Fall of the Roman Empire (US…Anthony Mann)
Une Femme Mariée (France…Jean-Luc Godard)
The Finest Hours (UK…Peter Bayliss)
A Fistful of Dollars (Italy…Sergio Leone)
The Flesh Eaters (US…Jack Curtis)
The Forest of the Hanged (Romania…Liviu Ciulei)
491 (Sweden…Vilgot Sjöman)
Gate of Flesh (Japan…Seijun Suzuki)
Gertrud (Denmark…Carl T.Dreyer)
Goldfinger (UK…Guy Hamilton)
The Gospel According to St Matthew (Italy…Pier Paolo Pasolini)
The Guns (Brazil…Ray Guerra)
Hamlet (USSR…Grigori Kozintsev)
Hamlet at Elsinore (UK…Philip Saville)
A Hard Day’s Night (UK…Richard Lester)
Hole in the Moon (Israel…Uri Zohar)
Hop Pickers (Czechoslovakia…Ladislav Rychman)
The Hunter’s Diary (Japan…Ko Nakahira)
The Husband Witnessed (Japan…Yasuzo Masumura)
I am Cuba (USSR/Cuba…Mikhail Kalatozov)
Identification Marks: None (Poland…Jerzy Skolimowski)
Intentions of Murder (Japan…Shohei Imamura)
The Jester’s Tale (Czechoslovakia…Karel Zeman)
The Killers (US…Don Siegel)
King and Country (UK…Joseph Losey)
Kwaidan (Japan…Masaki Kobayashi)
Let’s Talk About Women (Italy…Ettore Scola)
Lilith (US…Robert Rossen)
Loving Couples (Sweden…Mai Zetterling)
Manji (Japan…Yasuzo Masumura)
Man’s Favorite Sport (US…Howard Hawks)
Marnie (US…Alfred Hitchcock)
Marriage Italian Style (Italy…Vittorio de Sica)
Mary Poppins (US…Robert Stevenson)
The Masque of the Red Death (UK…Roger Corman)
The Moment of Truth (Italy…Francesco Rosi)
My Fair Lady (US…George Cukor)
The Night of the Iguana (US…John Huston)
No Holiday for Inochkin (USSR…Elem Klimov)
Not Reconciled, or Only Violence Helps Where Violence Rules (West Germany…Jean-Marie Straub, Danièle Huillet)
Nothing but the Best (UK…Clive Donner)
Onibaba (Japan…Kaneto Shindo)
Pale Flower (Japan…Masahiro Shinoda)
Les Parapluies de Cherbourg (France…Jacques Demy)
The Pawnbroker (US…Sidney Lumet)
The Peach Thief (Bulgaria…Vulo Radev)
Point of Order (US…Emile de Antonio)
The Pumpkin Eater (UK…Jack Clayton)
Robinson Crusoe on Mars (US…Byron Haskin)
Séance on a Wet Afternoon (UK…Bryan Forbes)
Seduced and Abandoned (Italy…Pietro Germi)
La Septième Jure (France…Georges Lautner)
Seven Days in May (US…John Frankenheimer)
Shadows of Our Forgotten Ancestors (USSR…Sergei Paradjanov)
The Shameless Old Lady (France…René Allio)
A Shot in the Dark (US/UK…Blake Edwards)
Something Else (Czechoslovakia…Vera Chytilova)
Strange Voyage (Spain…Fernando Fernan Gomez)
Swedish Wedding Night (Sweden…Ake Falck)
Sweet Sweat (Japan…Shiro Toyoda)
The Third Secret (UK…Charles Crichton)
Three Outlaw Samurai (Japan…Hideo Gosha)
To Love (Sweden…Jörn Donner)
The Tomb of Ligeia (UK…Roger Corman)
The Train (US…John Frankenheimer)
Two Stage Sisters (China…Xie Jin)
Virgin of Nuremberg (Italy…Antonio Margheriti)
Welcome, or No Trespassing (USSR…Elem Klimov)
Woman of the Dunes: director’s cut (Japan (2002)…Hiroshi Teshigahara)
World Without Sun (France…Jacques-Yves Cousteau)
Yearning (Japan…Mikio Naruse)
Zorba the Greek (UK/US…Michael Cocoyannis)
Zulu (UK…Cy Endfield)
—
Best Actor
—
Richard Attenborough Guns at Batasi
Stanley Baker Zulu
Alan Bates Nothing but the Best
Bernard Blier La Septième Juré
Dirk Bogarde King and Country
Richard Burton Becket
Richard Burton The Night of the Iguana
Charles Denner Life Upside Down
Kirk Douglas Seven Days in May
Peter Finch The Pumpkin Eater
Henry Fonda The Best Man
Henry Fonda Fail Safe
Rex Harrison My Fair Lady
Jarl Kulle Dear John
Lee Marvin The Killers
Peter O’Toole Becket
Christopher Plummer Hamlet at Elsinore TV
Vincent Price The Masque of the Red Death
Vincent Price The Tomb of Ligeia
Anthony Quinn Zorba the Greek
Victor Rebengiuc The Forest of the Hanged
Peter Sellers Doctor Strangelove
Innokenti Smoktunovky Hamlet
Rod Steiger The Pawnbroker
Saro Urzi Seduced and Abandoned
—
Best Actress
—
Harriet Andersson To Love
Julie Andrews Mary Poppins
Adriana Asti Before the Revolution
Anne Bancroft The Pumpkin Eater
Bette Davis Hush, Hush, Sweet Charlotte
Olivia de Havilland Hush, Hush, Sweet Charlotte
Catherine Deneuve Les Parapluies de Cherbourg
Deborah Kerr The Night of the Iguana
Kyoko Kishida Manji
Kyoko Kishida Woman of the Dunes
Sophia Loren Marriage, Italian Style
Macha Meril Une Femme Mariée
Jeanne Moreau The Diary of a Chambermaid
Madhabi Mukherjee Charulata
Nobuko Otawa Onibaba
Nina Pens Rode Gertrud
Moira Redmond Nightmare
Debbie Reynolds The Unsinkable Molly Brown
Christina Schollin Dear John
Jean Seberg Lilith
Kim Stanley Seance on a Wet Afternoon
Hideko Takamine Yearning
Constance Towers The Naked Kiss
Rita Tushingham Girl With Green Eyes
Monica Vitti Il Deserto Rosso
Ayako Wakao Manji
—
Best Supp Actor
—
Alan Bates Zorba the Greek
Shelley Berman The Best Man
Michael Caine Zulu
Melvyn Douglas The Americanization of Emily
Karel Effa The Jester’s Tale
Denholm Elliott Nothing but the Best
John Gielgud Becket
Alec Guinness The Fall of the Roman Empire
Larry Hagman Fail Safe
Sterling Hayden Doctor Strangelove
Stanley Holloway My Fair Lady
James Mason The Pumpkin Eater
Mikhail Nazvanov Hamlet
Edmond O’Brien Seven Days in May
Paul Scofield The Train
George C.Scott Doctor Strangelove
Robert Shaw Hamlet at Elsinore TV
Victor Spinetti A Hard Day’s Night
David Tomlinson Mary Poppins
Lee Tracy The Best Man
Peter Ustinov Topkapi
John Westbrook The Masque of the Red Death
—
Best Supp Actress
—
Harriet Andersson Loving Couples
Anastasia Bertinskaya Hamlet
Pamela Brown Becket
Julie Christie Young Cassidy
Edith Evans The Chalk Garden
Pamela Franklin The Third Secret
Grayson Hall The Night of the Iguana
Lila Kedrova Zorba the Greek
Gunnel Lindblom Loving Couples
Jennie Linden Nightmare
Agnes Moorehead Hush, Hush, Sweet Charlotte
Elza Radzinya Hamlet
Elizabeth Shepherd The Tomb of Ligeia
Maggie Smith The Pumpkin Eater
Emilia Vasaryova The Jester’s Tale
Anne Vernon Les Parapluies de Cherbourg
Jitsuko Yoshimura Onibaba
—
Best Cinematography
—
Henning Bendtsen Gertrud
Viktor Bestayev, Yuri Ilyenko Shadows of Our Forgotten Ancestors
Robert Burks Marnie
Raoul Coutard Une Femme Mariée
Tonino delli Colli The Gospel According to St Matthew
Carlo di Palma Il Deserto Rosso
Rune Ericson Dear John
Arthur Grant The Tomb of Ligeia
Jonas Gritsius Hamlet
Robert Krasker, John Moore The Fall of the Roman Empire
Kiyomi Kuroda Onibaba
Shigeyoshi Mine Gate of Flesh
Subrata Mitra Charulata
Yoshio Miyagima Kwaidan
Sven Nykvist Loving Couples
Jean Rabier Les Parapluies de Cherbourg
Nicolas Roeg The Masque of the Red Death
Hiroshi Segawa Woman of the Dunes
Harry Stradling My Fair Lady
Geoffrey Unsworth Becket
Sergei Urusevsky I am Cuba
Zhen Zhenxiang, Zhou Taming Two Stage Sisters
—
Best Score
—
John Barry Zulu
Giovanni Fusco, Vittorio Gelmenti Il Deserto Rosso
Hikaru Hayashi Onibaba
David Lee The Masque of the Red Death
Michel Legrand Les Parapluies de Cherbourg
Ennio Morricone A Fistful of Dollars
Satyajit Ray Charulata
Laurence Rosenthal Becket
Richard & Robert Sherman Mary Poppins*
Dimitri Shostakovich Hamlet
Toru Takemitsu Kwaidan
Toru Takemitsu Woman of the Dunes
Mikis Theodorakis Zorba the Greek
Dimitri Tiomkin The Fall of the Roman Empire
Tadashi Yamauchi Manji
—
* = Mary Poppins shouldn’t really be counted as nearly 100% instrumental versions of the songs, but it won the Oscar. Legrand’s score for Parapluies did include pieces beyond the songs.
—
Best Short
—
Alf, Bill & Fred (UK…Bob Godfrey)
Blowjob (US…Andy Warhol)
Canon (Canada…Norman McLaren & Grant Munro)
Dr. Devil and Mr. Hare (US…Robert McKimson)
Electronics in the World of Tomorrow (Finland…Erkki Kurenniemi)
Faces of November (US…Robert Drew)
The Great Steam Fair (UK…David Gladwell, Derrick Knight)
Magic Molecule (Canada…Christopher Chapman, Hugh O’Connor)
Memory (Japan…Osamu Tezuka)
Noviciat (France…Noël Burch)
Scorpio Rising (US…Kenneth Anger)
7 Up (UK…Michael Apted)
Song 1-8 (US…Stan Brakhage)
21-87 (Canada…Arthur Lipsett)
An Untitled Film (UK…David Gladwell)
—
